thereviews

Trust

How the score works

One equation, applied to every business, recomputed every time a review changes. Here it is in full, with an example you can check on a calculator.

The formula

score = (C × m + N × B) / (C + N)

B  = (Σ wᵢ × ratingᵢ + E × R) / (Σ wᵢ + E)    the blended rating
N  = Σ wᵢ + n                               how much evidence there is

m  = 3.5      starting point for every business
C  = 3        weight of that starting point, in reviews
wᵢ = recency × verification, for each review written here
     recency      = 0.5 ^ (age in days / 365)
     verification = 1.0 if verified, 0.7 if organic
R  = average rating on connected review sites, weighted by
     their review counts, ten-point scores halved to five
n  = number of reviews on those sites
E  = min(0.5 × n, 50)

Imported reviews count as organic reviews here, scaled as a group
so their weights sum to no more than max(Σ w of the rest, 3)

Every business starts at 3.5. That starting point counts as if it were 3 reviews, so one 5-star review moves a new business only a little, and it takes a handful of consistent reviews to reach a high score. This is why a business with two glowing reviews does not outrank one with two hundred good ones.

Each review carries a weight. A verified review posted today weighs exactly 1. The same review a year from now weighs 0.5, and two years from now 0.25. Organic reviews start at 0.7 and decay the same way. Old reviews never drop to zero, they just matter less than recent ones.

A business can connect its pages on other review sites: Google, Tripadvisor, Booking.com, Expedia, Agoda, Trip.com and others. Their ratings count too. In the blend each counts 0.5 of a review written here, because we cannot check who wrote them, and however many there are they never outweigh 50 verified reviews, so a business with thousands of reviews elsewhere still moves with what people write here. The starting point, though, is weighed against every review the business has, wherever it was written: a business with a thousand reviews averaging 4.9 scores 4.9, while one with two reviews still sits near the middle. Sites that republish other sites' reviews are not counted, so nobody is counted twice. The review count on a profile includes these sites; the star breakdown and the search-result stars cover reviews written on TheReviews only.

The score is rounded to one decimal place and shown with a label: 4.3 and above is Excellent, 3.8 is Great, 2.8 is Average, 1.8 is Poor, and anything below that is Bad.

Imported reviews

A business that moves to TheReviews from Trustpilot, Google, Reviews.io, Feefo, Yotpo or Judge.me can bring its old reviews with it, from that platform's own export file. Each one is shown with the reviewer's name, stars and words as the other platform held them, and a label saying where it came from, when it was imported and when it was first posted. A reply the business wrote there is shown underneath. Nobody can edit an imported review, and the business cannot reply to it here.

Imported reviews are never marked verified: we did not send the invitation and cannot see the order. In the formula each one is an organic review, weighing 0.7, and its age runs from the day it was first posted, so a review from three years ago weighs an eighth of a new one. On top of that they are capped as a group. Their combined weight never exceeds the combined weight of the reviews written on TheReviews, or 3 reviews' worth while the business has fewer than that here. When they would weigh more, every imported review is scaled down by the same factor, so the balance of their stars is kept but their say is limited. A business with a long history elsewhere starts out with a fair score; it does not start out finished.

The business must confirm it has the right to republish the reviews and that they are genuine and unedited. Duplicates, reviews already on the profile and rows dated in the future are skipped. A platform can be imported from once every 30 days, and a business can withdraw a whole import within 14 days. Every import and every withdrawal is listed in the business's public moderation log with the number of reviews and the platform. Imported reviews are not described to search engines as the business's rating: that markup covers reviews written on TheReviews only.

A worked example

Four reviews, computed live against today's date so the numbers below are exact.

ReviewRatingTypeAgeRecencyWeight ww × rating
AVerified12 days ago0.9770.9774.887
BOrganic3 months ago0.8430.5902.360
CVerified1.1 years ago0.4680.4680.936
DOrganic1.9 years ago0.2650.1850.926
Totals2.2219.109
score = (3 × 3.5 + 9.109) / (3 + 2.221)
      = 19.609 / 5.221
      = 3.8   (Great)

A plain average of the same four ratings would be 4.00. The score is lower because four reviews are not enough to move far from the starting point, and the two older reviews count for less.

Why it is built this way

Verified reviews weigh more, organic reviews still count.
A review tied to an order is harder to fake, so it gets full weight. We do not throw organic reviews away, because plenty of real customers never get an invitation.
Recent reviews weigh more.
Businesses change. A run of bad months three years ago should not follow a company that has fixed the problem, and a good reputation from 2021 should not cover for a bad 2026.
Nothing else goes in.
Not the plan the business pays for, not how many invitations it sends, not whether it replies. Reply rate is shown on the profile because readers find it useful, but it does not touch the score.

Fraud checks

Every new review is scored against the signals below. Points add up. A total of 40 or more holds the review for a person to read within one business day. A total of 90 or more blocks it outright. Anything below 40 publishes at once. The signals that fired are written to the transparency log in plain words, never the underlying data.

SignalFires whenPoints
Disposable email addressAccount email is on a known throwaway domain40
Account created less than a day agoAccount under a day old and the review is not verified10
Several reviews from the same account in 24 hoursThree or more reviews from the account in 24 hours25
Several reviews from the same network in 24 hoursThree or more reviews from the same network in 24 hours30
Several reviews from the same device in 24 hoursThree or more reviews from the same device in 24 hours30
Repeat reviews of this business from one networkTwo or more reviews of this business from one network in 30 days35
Submitted from the network that claimed the businessSubmitted from a network the business's own team has signed in from60
Text matches another reviewBody text identical to another review of the same business45
Contains a linkContains a link or web address15
Very shortFewer than 40 characters5
Extreme rating with little detail1 or 5 stars, under 60 characters, not verified10

Network addresses and device fingerprints are stored only as keyed hashes. We can tell two reviews came from the same place; we cannot tell where that place is. Details in the privacy policy.

Who gets asked, and what happened next

A rating is only as honest as the list of people asked for it. A business that invites only the customers it expects to be happy will look better than it is, and regulators in the UK and the US treat that as misleading. So every profile shows how its invitations were sent.

Store orders that got an invitation
Shopify and WooCommerce send us each fulfilled order directly, and the business cannot filter that feed by customer. We record every order we receive, invited or not, and show the share that got an invitation over the last 90 days. Orders that arrive without an email address are left out, because nobody could have invited them. The figure appears once there are 20 orders.
Invitations picked by hand
Invitations sent from the dashboard, a spreadsheet upload, Zapier or the API let the business choose who is asked. They are allowed, and counted here as picked by hand.
The Invites every customer mark
Shown when at least 95% of store orders got an invitation and at least 90% of all invitations came straight from the store, over 20 or more orders. It is checked every night and comes off as soon as either figure drops.
Problems resolved
When a business replies to a review of three stars or fewer, the reviewer can mark the problem resolved, or say it is not. Only the reviewer can answer, and they can change their mind. The business may ask once, by email, a day after replying. The profile shows how many of those reviews the reviewers say were resolved over the last twelve months, next to the median time the business takes to reply.

Questions about the score

Why does a business with two five-star reviews not score 5.0?

Every business starts at 3.5, and that starting point carries the weight of 3 reviews. Two verified five-star reviews posted today move the score to about 4.1. It takes a run of consistent reviews to reach the top of the scale, which is why two glowing reviews do not outrank two hundred good ones. Until a business has 3 reviews we do not show a score at all: the profile shows the plain average of its stars and says it is not scored yet, so nobody sees a number that is mostly the starting point.

Why can I see an average and a score?

The average is the plain mean of the stars people gave on TheReviews. The score runs those stars through the formula on this page, which weighs recent and verified reviews more, starts every business from the same point, and adds the business's ratings on its connected review sites. We show both so you can see what customers said here and how the business ranks overall.

Do reviews on Google or Booking.com count?

Yes, once the business connects those pages. In the blend each review on another site counts 0.5 of a review here, and all of them together never outweigh 50 verified reviews. They do count in full towards how sure the score is, so a business with hundreds of reviews elsewhere is not held back by the starting point. Booking.com, Expedia, Agoda, Trip.com and Traveloka score out of 10, so their ratings are halved to fit the five-star scale. Sites that only republish reviews from other sites are left out, so nobody is counted twice. The stars Google shows in search results describe reviews written on TheReviews only.

Do old reviews still count?

Yes, but less each year. A review's weight halves every 365 days: a verified review weighs 1.0 today, 0.5 after a year and 0.25 after two. Old reviews never drop to zero, they just matter less than recent ones.

Why do verified reviews weigh more than organic ones?

A review tied to an order is harder to fake, so it weighs 1.0. Organic reviews are written by anyone with a confirmed account and weigh 0.7. Both are shown on the profile and both are labelled.

When is a review held instead of published?

Each new review is scored against 11 signals with published point values. 40 points or more holds it for a person to read within one business day; 90 or more blocks it. Anything below 40 publishes at once, and the signals that fired are written to the transparency log in plain words.

What is an Editor's review?

A review written by a TheReviews editor after visiting or buying from the business. No business can pay for one or for what it says. It carries a gold tick, sits first on the profile, is signed by the team, and weighs the same as a verified review. There is never more than a handful per business and they are never sold.

Think a score is wrong?

Recompute it from the reviews and the connected-site ratings on the profile using the formula on this page. If the numbers do not match, that is a bug and we want to know through the contact form. If the reviews themselves look suspicious, report them from the review card and a person will look.

Think a score is wrong?

Recompute it from the reviews on the profile. If the numbers do not match, that is a bug and we want to know: contact us. If the reviews themselves look suspicious, report them from the review card and a person will look.